So back in January when I was working on our exposé on the Hatchetman Murders, I discovered to my chagrin that I had never taken pictures of the tombstone of Henry Hellman, old Andy’s son. Recently, we went back there and did that, and I thought, well, hey, might as well put something together that reviews the cemetery itself in official Headstoner style. So I’m back on it.

log-har-Jul52006-sunsetflag

As I described in my final Hatchetman post, “Harrod Cemetery is of a decent size, was established in 1898, though it has graves dating from before then, and is still in use. Some graves go back into the trees, but I don’t recommend poking around because the cemetery is fiercely bordered by poison ivy. It is well-maintained . . . Common last names include the eponymous ‘Harrod,’ as well as ‘Abel’ and ‘Oder.’ There is only one road through the cemetery, with two exits (or entrances, or one exit and one entrance), and the side closest to the twp. road is where the more modern burials are/continue to take place.”

It is one of the early Headstoner cemeteries, to be sure, and a lot of our research on the Andrew Hellman case influenced us in the founding of this website and our Headstoning cause of, well, you know, Headstoning (vb. To go from cemetery to cemetery to look at headstones). We go there a lot, frequently to kill time, or just as often to eat pickanick style. So I got to thinking that Herrod deserves a more thorough writeup of its own merits apart from the presence of the urban legendary Andrew “Hatchetman” Hellman.
log-har-Jun202009-HenryBut before we move away from the Hellmans entirely, I would like to dedicate a moment to dear Henry, dear Henry. Henry Hellman is one of my favorite dead guys. My surprise that I had previously never taken a picture of his tombstone before was partially fueled by the fact that it’s one of the neatest. His name (there’s a closeup in the gallery at the end) is all cool and wavy.

Just to recap the story briefly, Henry managed to escape the fate of his brother and sister (if, indeed, they were poisoned; Andrew repeatedly denied that he had murdered his children, but Henry himself asserted that poison was involved in his siblings’ deaths). The day his father killed his mother, Mrs. Hellman had sent him to her brother’s house (one of the Abels in the area), and this was how he avoided that fate as well. Check out my other posts on the Hellmans if you want more of the story. There’s a really fascinating anecdote about the young Henry (age 12, as I recall) being brought to the jail to see his father. Just because I don’t want to do the whole thing a third time, I’ll sum up with Henry living a good, full life, having married and had a daughter. On to the rest of the cemetery!
(more…)

Well, on May 23 we finally ventured back to Salem Cemetery outside Hendrysburg in Belmont County. We actually first went there during the great Topol Trip on Feb. 21, but knew nothing about it other than it was on our map of Ohio hauntings. Being ill prepared, we were (I was?) slightly freaked out by its location and the condition of the road so we drove back there but didn’t stop.

Bel-Salem-DSC00238

In our (my) defense, it should be noted that the Headstoners (read: me) have not so good luck and always seem to be the ones to face odd circumstances (see our TICO story). During that February trip, the gravel road (Salem Ridge Road) back to the cemetery was wet and half ice-covered, oh, and it had just been re-covered with gaint rocks. Not the ideal situation to visit a cemetery you’re not even sure you should be at. It was an adventure, though, and when we were in the eastern part of the state again and it hadn’t rained recently, we knew we had to go.

Bel-Salem-DSC00246This time, the road was much better. Not wet at all and those fresh stones had been compacted into what a gravel road should look like! Now that they’ve put signs up, it’s not hard to find either, but I’ll hold off on directions until the end.

The most well-known stone in the cemetery belongs to Louiza Catharine Fox  who was murdered by Thomas  Carr on Jan. 21, 1869, because her parents wouldn’t approve of their marriage. He actually became the first person hanged in the county, according to what I’ve read online. While we didn’t experience anything while we were there, the 13-year-old is apparently known to weep at her own grave. It’s also said that if you walk around the outside of the cemetery six times, you’ll disappear. This we didn’t have the time to try, and I’m not down with disappearing anyway!

Bel-Salem-DSC00253Over all, it’s a fairly large cemetery that is still actively used and taken care of. The older graves are toward the “bottom” (the west side) with the newer being farther up the hill. Louiza’s grave is down the hill and on the northern side, kind of alone and with objects around it (a broken pinwheel and fake flowers when we were there). It’s a really pretty area, that also boasts a second cemetery.

Circle Cemetery (as it is known, not sure of the real name) is a little farther down the main road, where the road forks again, on the right (south). There aren’t very many graves there, and most of them are in poor condition, fallen over and sunk into the ground. (more…)

Well, returning after the brief break to give you an update on more cemeteries hit during our Topolicious weekend, let me just give a few words of introduction before getting started. I will confess being very excited about this, because as much as we owe Beth over at GraveAddiction, and as grateful as I am for her ongoing support and interest, I have wanted to make sure our blog didn’t just become an echo of her website. “Oh, yes, she’s right–there is a cemetery here with a tombstone in it!” And, though granted it’s nice to get different perspectives on the same place and there are a limited number of cemeteries, I was looking forward to when we could spice up our blog with a little variety and “where no man has gone before” action. So I now present to you . . .

Northwood Cemetery--A Headstoner's Original!

Northwood Cemetery--A Headstoner's Original!

Northwood Cemetery, first of all, is huge, and it is located in the north part of Cambridge, go figure. It made the “Hidden Ohio” map and ForgottenOhio website for, if I may quote ForgottenOH briefly, “A lady in a 1920s-style white gown is seen roaming between the tombstones here on certain summer nights, only to disappear shortly thereafter.” However, the Hidden Ohio directions are poor beyond reason, and so I shall try to provide you with some. I’m not very good at directions, so perhaps my fellow Headstoner would like to update this portion of the post at some point! Anyway, here are my simplistic directions: once in Cambridge, begin by going east on Wheeling Ave., which also just happens to be Route 40. Turn left onto 10th street, which will eventually dead end into the entrace you see before you. That seems too easy, but I leave it to MFH to correct me if I’m wrong . . . or elaborate if I’m simple. Or sing if I will dance. Or . . . wait.

One of the many (closed) entrances!

One of the many (closed) entrances!

Okay, so, welcome to Northwood Cemetery, a truly massive and impressive specimen, containing a wide variety of sights and sites that range from the bizarrely ecclectic to the modern. Indeed, there is enough here to tantalize any taphophile to return. (Forgive me–I’ve spent the morning doing a Marvin Mudrick book for work and he’s infected my speech patterns with alliteration. I’ll try to tone it down.) Beyond the fact that Northwood is completely huge, with at least six entrances (please note that only the one I’ve directed you to is open–or was at our visit, it also seems to be a popular hangout for locals to either walk or jog. This may have to do with its sharing one border with the city park. Although it was too cold to get out and look around, I did note that there seem to be a variety of walking trails, and plenty of civilization close by for a not-so-dedicated explorer. (more…)

Herrod Cemetery

Harrod Cemetery

So now I’m back for the next bit on Andrew Hellman. Hope I didn’t leave anybody hanging! (Pun intended. Haha.)

I first read this ghost story in a Logan county newspaper a long time ago and didn’t think much of that. For awhile, we disinterestedly tried to find the cemetery “Hatchetman” was said to haunt–Harrod Cemetery on Twp. Road 56–though it took us awhile. Just because it’s fun, here’s the longitude and latitude of Harrod Cemetery: 40.423172,-83.783855. 

Harrod Cemetery is of a decent size, was established in 1898, though it has graves dating from before then, and is still in use. Some graves go back into the trees, but I don’t recommend poking around because the cemetery is fiercely bordered by poison ivy. It is well-maintained, and apparently haunted. Which is what I hope to bust in this post. Common last names include the eponymous “Harrod,” as well as “Abel” and “Oder.” There is only one road through the cemetery, with two exits (or entrances, or one exit and one entrance), and the side closest to the twp. road is where the more modern burials are/continue to take place.

On our first visit, we verified a few things. First of all, that Louisa and John Hellman were born and died when they should have and were buried there. (Note that according to the source I tagged in the last post, Louisa and John were buried in the same grave.) That small white stone is barely legible, but it does belong to Mary Hellman.

Louisa and John Hellman

Louisa and John Hellman

Mary Hellman's Stone

Mary Hellman's Stone

Additionally, proving that Henry did survive, there is a small cluster of graves belonging to him and his family in the southwest part of the cemetery. For some inexplicable reason, even though Henry is my favorite, we don’t have any pictures of his marker–which is very pretty, too! I don’t understand that. We have to do something about that. He’s cool.

(more…)

Today I’d like to tell a ghost story. We’re beginning to acquire a reputation for ghost-busting, and I kind of like this reputation, so I’m going to keep it up. So here’s the story, accentuated with quotations from an account in an 1844 atlas (which appears to be a synopsis of the longer account seen here).

The year was 1843. A good year, by all accounts; a common year starting on a Sunday. A Christmas Carol is first published. Edgar Allan Poe publishes “The Tell-Tale Heart.” Frederick VIII, King of Denmark, was born, though presumably was not king yet. Henry James was born. Good for him. A few good deaths–Noah Webster, for one–but one death caused attention to stir in at least two states that had been irrevocably touched by the “blood-stained wretch.” Which would be the death I’m going to talk about today.

The date was January 12, which has prompted me to post this now, 164 years later to the day. Andrew Hellman, alias Adam Horn, was hanged in Champaign County for the offense of murder. Lots of people got executed in Ohio for murder that year. But not a lot of them ended up getting a whole urban legend dedicated to them. Here’s how the story goes.

Part I. Andy H. was born in Worms on 24 June 1792 and immigrated to America in 1820. He was either a farmer or a taior by trade. He found himself in the good graces of the Abel family of Loudon County, Virginia, and, in the colorful language of the day, “was allowed to engage the affections of one of [Farmer Abel's] daughters . . . Mary Abel . . . then in her twentieth year, a blithe, buxom, and light-hearted country girl, whose previous existence had never been marred by unhappiness or misery. The arch-fiend, Hellman, succeeded in smothering his feelings of hatred, thus showin that even his wooing was characterized by duplicity and deceit.” To shorten it, they were married in December 1821.

Hellman, characterized as a fiend, bloody devil, etc., had added to his epitaphs “unnatural father” when Louisa was born in 1822. Two more children followed by 1836, and these were Henry and John. (Apparently this “unnatural father” declared to his wife that if a fourth child were ever to be born, he would kill her.) Hellman bought a farm not far from a brother-in-law’s in Logan County, Ohio, and proceeded to “deny his family everything but the bare necessities of life.” He attempted and failed to poison his wife, and then poisoned his three children; John and Louisa died in April. (For what it’s worth, old Hellman denied having poisoned them.) Five months later, Hellman completely flipped his lid, if you will, and went after Mary with a hatchet. (According to Henry’s own testimony, his mother sent him out of the house to his uncle’s, thus saving his life.) “The mutilated remains of the poor wife were found in a room of the house,” and old Andy H. was arrested. He tried to say that there had been a robber who had wounded him, but a physician pronounced him unharmed. Despite being arrested, he broke out of jail in Bellefontaine, Ohio, and escaped. His wife was buried with Louisa and John in Harrod Cemetery in McArthur Township, the final resting place of a great deal of the Abel clan.

Part II. Andy escapes from prison in Bellefontaine, flees to Maryland, and adopts the name Adam Horn. For some reason, he gets married again, this time to Malinda Hinkle. The honeymoon didn’t last long, as shortly after that, he not only killed her, but cut up her body and hid the remains all over the farm. “The head was severed from the trunk, and was never found, despite the most minute search. The body was found partly in an up-stairs room of the house, and the remainder buried in a coffee sack in a gully which traversed Hellman’s orchard.” (Instant urban legend material.) He was tried and pronounced guilty. He was subsequently executed in Champaign County, Ohio. (Declaration and death warrant.) (Also, interestingly, a review of his confession.) (Description of the execution.)

Now, perhaps I’ve given too many details and too many citations for it to be much of a ghost story, so I’ll get on with it. According to the legend, Andrew Hellman, buried in the same cemetery as his first wife and three children, haunts the nearby Township Road 56, terrorizing drivers, particularly females, whose cars break down on the road. His tombstone is also said to glow.

I know there weren’t any pictures in this post. I’m leaving it there. Tomorrow I’ll be back to BUST this story . . . I hope.

cha-kin-1220091499Today, still moving away from Green Lawn, however briefly, I’d like to tell you guys a ghost story! Well, it is my department. I wouldn’t want to disappoint my fans. So here’s a little ghost story about Clark Road in Urbana, Champaign County, Ohio.

Once upon a time, there was a guy, and even though his name was not Jack (I don’t think), he built a house – a beautiful house in the country where he intended to live with his wife and children. Stop me if you’ve heard this one before ;-) Or just go watch The Haunting.

Anyway, while he was building the house or shortly after finishing it, his wife and children died in a train accident. En route? I don’t know–if they were, that really smacks of The Haunting, so I’m inclined to say forget that thread. Who was he? Did he really exist? At the moment, I don’t know, but I promise the Headstoners will return to this topic to let you know the truth on the subject. Right now, the truth is off-topic. What’s on topic is the house that the guy who wasn’t Jack built.

Hell House

Hell House

Satan's Piggies

Satan's Piggies

After the death of his wife and children, the builder of the house set his work on fire and hanged himself from the oak tree in his front yard. However, though he died, the house itself mysteriously did not burn down. It exhibited charring, and yet continued to stand for an indeterminate amount of time. That wasn’t the place’s only mystery–website lore maintained that the suicide’s body could be seen, occasionally, at night, hanging from a branch of the tree that hung over the road, though by the time my fellow headstoner and I made it there to see, the tree had no branches hanging over the road. The house itself was not actually abandoned and appeared to be in use . . . as a barn. A few cute little pigs came out to greet us when we drove by, but we didn’t stay long enough to figure out who might belong to them. Who the heck uses a haunted/abandoned house for a barn?! (There was a cow hanging around, too.)

Still, that was in 2005. Today, Hell House no longer exists, having been demolished by its owners who apparently decided to invest in a proper barn. However, our Clark Road explorations revealed something that we may not have have discovered otherwise: a place we rather fondly nicknamed Hell Cemetery in honor of Hell House. (more…)

fran-gre-dscn54451I have been preoccupied with the C. H. Hayden mausoleum pretty much since we started frequenting Green Lawn when I was a child. The first time I saw it, a seven-year-old anklebiter, I thought a president was buried there, or someone as important. It was a veritable Taj Mahal–and still, four or five of the standard tombs located around Green Lawn could fit inside this edifice, easy. It was constructed in 1904 and sits in the center of the cemetery by the lake. Most of my information on it comes from Andy at ForgottenOH.

Additionally, it marks the spot of pretty much the beginning of mine and Kristine’s first real cemetery exploit. It was September of 2003 and we were driving to Columbus. On the way down, I received a phone call telling me I was out of a job. I was more surprised than anything else, and to celebrate, we decided to have a picnic. This was unusual for us, to say the least; we swung through KFC and then tried to decide where to eat. Somehow we decided to go to Green Lawn; somehow we wound up on the steps of Hayden’s mausoleum. We settled down with a pretty decent spread of southern-fried goodness: crispy chicken, baked beans, coleslaw, biscuits. We speculated on the identity of “C. H. Hayden” and worked on a novel in a notebook.

I don’t remember anything else about that, but four months later, we were back with a video camera, and somewhere in the foggy interim, an obsession was born. Now every time we visit Green Lawn, we swing by to say hello to Hayden, even though we’ve learned a few things about him since.

fran-gre-dscn54411

This is the final resting place of Columbus banker Charles H. Hayden . . . and seven other people, apparently. At least potentially. Actually, nothing but vagueness surrounds both the potential interments here and the ghost story apparently related to it. All I know for sure is that the tomb was comissioned in 1904 and Chuck died shortly after. There are a lot of . . . actually, there aren’t a lot of stories. There’s just one story. That story says that if you knock on the door, someone will knock back. There is a tantalizing rumor about a potential “more substantial manifestation,” too, but no evidence as of yet to actual existance of the same.

Here is one fruitless attempt to get a response from Hayden, me from July of this year:

fran-gre-dscn54421

fran-gre-dscn54441

As can be expected, he wasn’t home. Here’s another, video this time, from just this month:

As you can see, the old boy has yet to respond to me. But . . . someday I may get lucky! Apparently there is also the ghost of a little boy who hangs around crying, but I’ve never seen him, either.

What about you? Any ghost stories?

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.